# PINBALL POPULARITY: CLASSIC vs. CURRENT POP CULTURE THEMES **Source:** Pinball News Website **Type:** article **Published:** 2017-02-17 **Beat:** Pinball **URL:** https://www.pinballnews.com/site/2017/02/17/1658 --- ## Analysis An industry perspective on pinball's resurgence driven by nostalgic collectors willing to pay premium prices for both refurbished classic machines and new licensed games. The article contrasts collector demand for 1990s classics (Addams Family, Medieval Madness, Twilight Zone) against new manufacturer offerings themed around current pop culture, noting both segments are thriving. Historic pricing data shows significant appreciation: a 2003 Stern Simpsons machine has doubled in value, while rare Bally/Williams titles command $12,000–$15,000. ### Key Claims - [MEDIUM] The Addams Family is the top-selling modern pinball machine to date — _Article cites this as historical fact with external link to Gizmodo; no manufacturer verification provided_ - [HIGH] Classic pinball machines require more maintenance than arcade video games (Pong era), contributing to their phase-out from commercial venues in the mid-to-late 1980s — _Stated as industry historical fact; aligns with widely accepted pinball market history_ - [HIGH] A 2003 Stern Simpsons Pinball Party that retailed for $3,695 now sells for close to $6,000 refurbished (14 years later) — _Specific pricing data from M&P Amusement distributor; verifiable through secondary market_ - [HIGH] Cactus Canyon (last Bally/Williams title) had fewer than 1,000 units produced and now sells for $12,000–$15,000 restored — _Specific production and pricing data from M&P Amusement distributor; consistent with known rarity_ - [MEDIUM] Planetary Pinball remade Medieval Madness; the new standard version retails for ~$8,500 while original machines sell for ~$10,000 — _Pricing cited but Planetary Pinball remake details not independently verified in article_ - [LOW] Top 10 highest-rated pinball machines are mostly from the 1990s — _Stated as assertion without citation or ranking source provided_ - [MEDIUM] Most commercial locations purchase new pinball machines for reliability reasons — _Industry observation stated without data; reasonable but not empirically supported in article_ - [MEDIUM] A single pinball machine contains over a mile of wire — _Technical specification stated without source; common industry claim but not verified here_ ### Notable Quotes > "The pinball market is having a huge resurgence largely because those who grew up playing it can now purchase machines for their homes." > — **Gene Goodman (M&P Amusement VP)**, null > _Core thesis explaining collector-driven market resurgence; identifies demographic driver_ > "Rather than new games based on popular TVs and movies like Star Wars, it's the classic, refurbished games that they are willing to pay for." > — **Gene Goodman**, null > _Directly contrasts collector preference for classics over modern licensed IP; positions Star Wars as example of contemporary theme_ > "While new pinball machines look and play fantastic, there is even a larger demand for the classic games people remember playing when they grew up." > — **Gene Goodman**, null > _Quantifies relative market demand; acknowledges new machines' quality while asserting classic preference_ > "It does not matter how many times you play the same pinball machine, you will never have the same game twice." > — **Gene Goodman**, null > _Philosophical statement on pinball's appeal; emphasizes replayability and variance as value proposition_ > "These limited games have features that you cannot get in the standard models. Collectors will snatch up a lot of these games, but their game room is also filled with the greatest titles of the past." > — **Gene Goodman**, null > _Identifies manufacturer strategy (LE premium features) and collector behavior (hybrid collecting of old and new)_ ### Entities | Name | Type | Context | |------|------|---------| | Gene Goodman | person | Vice President of M&P Amusement; author; long-established distributor of refurbished pinball machines | | M&P Amusement | company | Distributor of new and refurbished arcade/pinball machines since 1932; headquarters York, Pennsylvania; source of pricing data | | Planetary Pinball | company | Company that remade Medieval Madness; noted as responding to demand for classic Williams titles | | The Addams Family | game | Classic pinball machine; cited as top-selling modern pinball machine to date; high collector demand | | Attack From Mars | game | Classic pinball machine; listed among top collector demand titles | | Twilight Zone | game | Classic pinball machine; listed among top collector demand titles | | Medieval Madness | game | Classic Williams game; remade by Planetary Pinball; original retails ~$10,000 vs. new standard version ~$8,500 | | The Simpsons Pinball Party | game | 2003 Stern title; retailed $3,695 new; now sells refurbished for ~$6,000 | | Cactus Canyon | game | Last Bally/Williams title; <1,000 units produced; now sells for $12,000–$15,000 restored | | Star Wars | game | Modern pinball IP; used as example of current pop culture themed games vs. classic collector preference | | Stern | company | Major pinball manufacturer; produced The Simpsons Pinball Party (2003) | | Bally/Williams | company | Historic pinball manufacturer; produced Medieval Madness, Cactus Canyon, and other classic titles | | Pong | game | Arcade video game; cited as driver of pinball displacement from commercial venues in mid-to-late 1980s | ### Topics - **Primary:** Collector demand for classic pinball machines and pricing appreciation, Pinball market resurgence driven by nostalgic home collectors, New licensed IP pinball games vs. classic games as collector preference - **Secondary:** Historical decline of pinball in commercial venues (1980s-1990s), Maintenance burden and reliability differences between pinball and arcade video games, Refurbishment market and parts availability for classic machines, Limited edition and premium tier pricing strategy in modern pinball manufacturing, Secondary market pricing and value appreciation of vintage pinball ### Sentiment **Positive** (0.82) — Optimistic tone on pinball resurgence, collector enthusiasm, and dual-demand market health. Author celebrates both classic and modern machines thriving simultaneously. No criticism of manufacturers or negative industry outlook. Minor acknowledgment of maintenance complexity in classics but framed as part of collector appeal (history, authenticity). ### Signals - **[business_signal]** Manufacturer strategy shift: current pinball manufacturers (implied Stern, JJP, others) adopting limited edition and premium tier models to capture collector demand (confidence: medium) — Quote: 'The current pinball manufacturers caught on to that and started offering premium and limited edition versions of their games. These limited games have features that you cannot get in the standard models.' - **[business_signal]** Refurbishment and parts business expansion: growing market of companies nationwide refurbishing classic machines and stocking parts (noted as industry trend) suggests profitable aftermarket ecosystem (confidence: medium) — Statement: 'There are several companies stocking pinball parts and artwork for the classic pinball machines. You can find companies all over the country refurbishing and selling pinball games now.' - **[market_signal]** Dual-market health: both new licensed IP games and classic refurbished machines thriving; operators prefer new (reliability), collectors prefer classics (nostalgia), supporting different market segments (confidence: high) — New vs. Classic section distinguishes commercial operator preference (new) from collector preference (classic) - **[market_signal]** Significant secondary market price appreciation: 2003 Stern Simpsons (+62% over 14 years) and Cactus Canyon rarity premium ($12k–$15k for <1,000 units) signal strong collector-driven valuation of licensed IP from early 2000s Stern era (confidence: high) — Specific pricing: Simpsons $3,695 → $6,000; Cactus Canyon $12,000–$15,000 for restored units - **[market_signal]** Original classics command premium over modern remakes: Medieval Madness original ~$10,000 vs. Planetary Pinball remake ~$8,500, suggesting collectors value authenticity and history over brand-new condition (confidence: medium) — Pricing comparison: 'The new standard version of Medieval Madness retails for around $8,500, while the original retails for almost $10,000.' - **[sentiment_shift]** Collector preference paradox: despite acknowledgment that new machines 'look and play fantastic,' classic machines command higher prices and greater collector demand, indicating nostalgia/authenticity weighs more than features (confidence: high) — Quote: 'While new pinball machines look and play fantastic, there is even a larger demand for the classic games people remember playing when they grew up.' --- ## Transcript Back in the early 1970s to the early 1990s, you could find pinball machines everywhere. You would see them in your local bars, arcade, restaurants, bowling alleys, and even your corner stores. Pinball made game operators a lot of money but required a lot of maintenance. Pinball machines have several moving parts plus over a mile of wire in a single pinball. With more parts in a game, the higher the chance of something going wrong. In the mid to late ’80s, arcade video games like Pong started taking over at these same commercial locations. They became the product to push since they required less maintenance and game play could be more easily controlled. Timed play made it easier for the venue to make more money. Pinball machines were slowly phased out at this point and became harder to find for those folks that lived for the game. The pinball market is having a huge resurgence largely because those who grew up playing it can now purchase machines for their homes. Rather than new games based on popular TVs and movies like Star Wars, it’s the classic, refurbished games that they are willing to pay for. It is amazing to see so many new companies building great pinball machines again. While new pinball machines look and play fantastic, there is even a larger demand for the classic games people remember playing when they grew up. They want to face that machine again that they almost mastered before. Titles like The Addams Family, Attack From Mars, and Twilight Zone are bringing top dollar, with The Addams Family being the top-selling modern pinball machine to date. !The Addams Family The Addams Family Pinball collectors want these classic pinball machines refurbished; looking and playing like new games. The top 10 highest rated pinball machines are mostly pinball games from the 1990s. New vs. Classic Pinball Machines New pinball sales are also doing great. Most commercial locations buy new machines because of the reliability. Most new pinball machines are license-themed games with current movies, or bands. These new games come with great new features that can capture our attention immediately, whereas, the classic games bring back memories of youth and a desire to own the game they remember. There are several companies stocking pinball parts and artwork for the classic pinball machines. You can find companies all over the country refurbishing and selling pinball games now. One company, Planetary Pinball, saw the demand for Williams pinball titles and remade one of the best pinball machines ever called Medieval Madness. !The Medieval Madness remake The Medieval Madness remake Even with a new version of this game available, folks are willing to pay more for an original Medieval Madness pinball. The new standard version of Medieval Madness retails for around $8,500, while the original retails for almost $10,000. !Medieval Madness Medieval Madness Pinball Collectors The growing retro market has led to a large market for collectors as well. The current pinball manufacturers caught on to that and started offering premium and limited edition versions of their games. These limited games have features that you cannot get in the standard models. Collectors will snatch up a lot of these games, but their game room is also filled with the greatest titles of the past. Our customers range from pinball collectors to folks just starting in the hobby. There is a sense of pride when showing off your pinball machine to friends and family. They found the game they have been on the hunt for. Folks love seeing older classic pinball machines that look and play like a brand new game. With the older games there is a bit of history that comes with it. Back in 2003 a brand new, in the box, Stern The Simpsons Pinball Party retailed for $3,695.00. That same game, now, 14 years later is bringing close to $6,000.00 refurbished. The price of well-known and trusted titles keep going up. One of the last titles to come out from Bally/Williams was Cactus Canyon. Less than 1,000 of these games were made and they now can sell for $12,000-$15,000 for restored machines. New pinball games are keeping pinball current again. That, in itself, is great news for pinball lovers. With the demand for both new and classic pinball machines, these games will become easier to find again. It does not matter how many times you play the same pinball machine, you will never have the same game twice. About the Author Gene Goodman is vice president of M&P Amusement, a distributor of new and quality refurbished used arcade games and pinball machines since 1932, with headquarters in York, Pennsylvania. _(Acquisition: raw_text, Enrichment: v1)_ --- *Exported from Journalist Tool on 2026-04-13 | Item ID: 3edf5d7a-ef05-4179-be7a-9c9a908bcd2b*