claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 · $0.034
Harry Potter AI art scandal and Predator licensing woes dominate two major June 2025 pinball releases.
Jersey Jack Pinball initially denied AI use in Harry Potter art; artist Jesper Abels later admitted using AI tools 'sparingly and intentionally' without informing JJP leadership
high confidence · Kevin and Nick discussing the art controversy and reading Jesper Abels' statement on the podcast
Harry Potter playfield features unusual in-lane-out-lane configuration similar to JGP Pirates with a drop target save mechanic on the right side and no wire form returns to inlanes
high confidence · Kevin describing playfield mechanics during Harry Potter review segment
Jersey Jack Pinball did not finish code on Godfather and took 7 years to complete Pirates; Avatar and Wonka reportedly have completed code
medium confidence · Kevin expressing concerns about JJP's code completion track record as reason for holding off on Harry Potter purchase
Predator machine is being manufactured in Italy with unknown US tariffs on top of MSRP, likely bringing total cost to ~$15K for top package
high confidence · Kevin and Nick calculating final US pricing including shipping and tariffs for Predator
Pinball Brothers cannot show close-ups or use Arnold Schwarzenegger's likeness due to licensing; they have a substitute voice actor instead
high confidence · Kevin referencing CEO statements on Tell All News and Loser Kid podcasts; discussing blurred/cropped Arnold footage on Predator video
Heighway Pinball (not Pinball Brothers) manufactured Alien; Pinball Brothers has made Queen and ABBA
high confidence · Kevin correcting Nick's attribution of Alien manufacturer during Predator discussion
Harry Potter art analysis identified AI-generation artifacts including four-fingered hands and a dragon with an extra eye (second gill-like feature)
high confidence · Kevin and Nick discussing Bumpergeist's art comparison analysis on Tilt Forums and examining specific dragon anomaly
“To me, pinball is a work of art. But still, for the sake of a joke, you're melting down over expensive toys.”
Kevin Manning @ early show — Characterizes the tension between pinball's artistic merit and community drama on Pinside forums
“People were losing their minds for this. There was some, you know, obviously there's always critiques of games and things like that, but universally it was pretty much loved and admired.”
Kevin Manning @ Harry Potter segment — Establishes that Harry Potter had overwhelmingly positive reception before art controversy
“It's not a good sign when you're touting that your flippers work correctly. That's a low bar.”
Nick Lane @ Predator discussion — Nick's critical take on Pinball Brothers promoting improved flippers as a feature
“I have zero confidence. If they had made amazing games all along... But the fact that there's so much in the air and then they showed this gameplay footage, and it looks, the geometry looks kind of janky.”
Nick Lane @ Predator analysis — Expresses skepticism about Pinball Brothers' capability based on track record and initial footage
“Italians don't know how to make a pinball machine.”
Nick Lane @ Predator hot take — Provocative statement about Pinball Brothers' manufacturing origin and quality concerns
“Every instance of AI was guided by my own artistic vision and layered onto handcrafted designs. It was never about replacing the human element as it was about enhancing it.”
Jesper Abels @ artist statement reading — Artist's justification for AI use; Kevin notes the language patterns typical of AI-generated text
“I'm being an adult. I'm using some restraint, waiting to see, get my hands on it and see where we're at code-wise.”
Kevin Manning @ Harry Potter decision section — Kevin's measured approach to purchasing despite hype, citing code completion concerns
announcement: Jersey Jack Pinball officially reveals Harry Potter machine in three tiers ($10K-$15K) with Mina Lima art and Joe Cass code
high · Kevin: 'First up is the long-awaited, much-rumored, and speculated Harry Potter pinball machine by Jersey Jack Pinball. They came in three models, a collector's edition for $15,000, a wizard edition for $12,000, and an arcade edition for $10,000.'
product_concern: Harry Potter art contains AI-generation artifacts (four-fingered hands, dragon with extra eye) not disclosed by artist to manufacturer; Jesper Abels admits to using AI tools without informing Jersey Jack leadership
high · Bumpergeist analysis identified multiple AI artifacts; Jesper Abels' statement admits 'AI tools were used sparingly and intentionally' but 'not everyone involved in the project had direct knowledge or understanding of these technologies'
announcement: Pinball Brothers officially reveals Predator machine (wide-body, jungle theme, $11K-$12.5K base, ~$15K with tariffs/shipping in US)
high · Kevin: 'The second pinball machine revealed this month is another long-awaited one... Pinball Brothers giving it a shot... They finally... decided to go ahead and reveal Predator'
product_concern: Predator machine cannot show Arnold Schwarzenegger close-ups or use his actual voice; substitute voice actor used instead due to licensing restrictions
high · Kevin: 'The CEO from the company was on podcast saying, we can't show Arnold... we can't show close-ups of Arnold, and we have all of the rest of the movie, all the call-outs and everything, except for Arnold. So they have somebody in the game that kind of not really at all sounds like Arnold.'
groq_whisper · $0.363
“With the way the prices have been dropping on the second-hand market, it's like if you end up not liking a game, you're going to end up losing $3,000, a couple thousand dollars right off the bat.”
Kevin Manning @ market discussion — Signals secondary market depreciation affecting buying decisions
code_update: Harry Potter code is at version 0.7x with reported crashes from high-level player Vuvuf; Kevin cites Jersey Jack's poor track record of code completion (Pirates took 7 years, Godfather unfinished) as reason to delay purchase
high · Kevin: 'the code is only at .7 something and DJP... doesn't have the best track record... did finally finish Pirates but it was 7 years after the fact Godfather is still waiting for a final code update'
sentiment_shift: Harry Potter shifted from 'overwhelmingly the most positive reception' to divided community response after AI art controversy; some collectors (like James) backing out despite movie enthusiasm
high · Kevin: 'up until like the art controversy thing happened, it was overwhelmingly the most positive reception I've seen for a pinball machine.' Later: 'Our buddy James... he's like, a huge movie buff, was totally stoked for this Predator game... he's not getting it.'
market_signal: Predator pricing includes hidden costs (shipping from Italy, unknown US tariffs) pushing actual cost to ~$15K; Kevin notes secondary market depreciation ($2-3K losses) affecting purchase decisions
high · Kevin: 'you're looking at probably around $15,000 to get this to your door if you want the top-level package in the U.S.' and 'With the way the prices have been dropping on the second-hand market, it's like if you end up not liking a game, you're going to end up losing $3,000, a couple thousand dollars right off the bat'
competitive_signal: Nick expresses zero confidence in Pinball Brothers' capability based on track record (Queen, ABBA) versus Highway Pinball's Alien success; questions playfield geometry and calls flippers marketing a 'low bar'
high · Nick: 'Pinball Brothers did not make Alien. Highway Pinball made Alien. So they've proven at no point that they're capable of making a good pinball machine... I have zero confidence.'
design_innovation: Harry Potter features unusual in-lane-out-lane configuration (similar to Pirates of the Caribbean) with drop target save mechanic and no wire form returns to inlanes—distinctive from typical modern machines
high · Kevin: 'He's got an unusual in-lane-out-lane configuration. It's more like JGP Pirates. But on the right-hand side, there's a little drop target that can pop up and save your ball... There are also no wire form returns to the inlanes, which I think is really interesting.'
business_signal: Pinball Brothers manufacturing in Italy and passing tariff costs to US customers; suggests supply chain complexity and potential margin pressure
medium · Kevin: 'they're being made in italy... and then shipping from the distributor to your house and then they're also imposing tariffs on top of that which are unknown at this time'
content_signal: Multiple podcasts (Tell All News, Loser Kid) covering Predator licensing issues; YouTube gameplay footage shows blurred/cropped Arnold and substitute voice—heavy community scrutiny of licensing compromises
high · Kevin: 'it was on the Tell All News podcast and also on Loser Kid. I listened to both of those... they do the Get to the Chopper clip... they have this weird, like, really bad voice actor, and... Arnold's face is blurred out and cropped.'
community_signal: Pinside forums and Tilt Forums show vocal community revolts over Harry Potter AI art use; comparison to video game industry responses; Kevin notes AI language patterns in artist's apology statement
high · Kevin: 'I'm 99% sure the guy used AI to help write the statement' based on language patterns. 'when video games have been found to use AI like this, there's been full-on revolts... it has definitely happened, at least for a vocal group on Pinside and in the forums'