claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 · $0.040
SDTM 2024 year-end review awards Jaws best game; discusses industry failures and licensing struggles.
Jaws was the best-selling game collectively across Pro, Premium, and all models through Flippin' Out Pinball in 2024, out of any title still being manufactured
high confidence · Greg Bone stating sales data from Flippin' Out Pinball distributor
Barrels of Fun's Labyrinth sold more units than any single model variant of Jaws
high confidence · Greg Bone comparing sales figures across manufacturers
John Wick pinball machine was not a hot seller upon release
medium confidence · Zach Menny's subjective assessment of market reception
Haggis Pinball went into liquidation in August 2024, causing customers who bought direct to lose money
high confidence · Greg Bone confirming liquidation event and customer losses
Stern Pinball returned to three cornerstones in 2024 after previously doing two cornerstones
medium confidence · Hosts discussing Stern's release strategy shift
Greg Ferris retired as head of Stern art department mid-2024
high confidence · Hosts explicitly stating his retirement from the position
Godzilla 70th Anniversary Premium Edition was released in July 2024 with Shane Black and Dick White art variant, and was retired/sold out by end of year
high confidence · Greg Bone confirming release, artwork style, and sell-out status
Spooky Pinball's Scooby-Doo interactive topper accessory was priced at $999
high confidence · Greg Bone stating the retail price
“I still think that just, I know the shark debacle, but like still hitting that boat, it's a lot harder to hit than the Pro to do that. Like I love that.”
Zach Menny@ 5:03 — Discussing Jaws Premium Edition mechanical advantage and gameplay quality
“There's not even a second place that's close to it, because the one thing that sets it apart is the way the rules open up as you play.”
Greg Bone@ 6:46 — Establishing Jaws' superiority in 2024 game design and rules complexity
“I don't know what the hell they were doing. I don't know what the hell they were doing, Greg. So I, I mean, I agree. I don't think that you could have honestly done any worse.”
Zach Menny@ 14:07 — Criticizing Barry's Barbecue Challenge design and theme execution
“A barbecue joint? Because barbecue joints are known for being quick. Yes. Like, it's not like they're grilling a steak where you want somebody to stick around.”
Greg Bone@ 15:09 — Analyzing flawed venue strategy for Barry's Barbecue Challenge placement
“I don't know many people were calling for a John Wick pinball machine... I think that it kind of missed its market. Maybe should have been done a few years earlier.”
Zach Menny@ 18:44 — Assessing licensing timing and market relevance issues with John Wick
“And I hate to say this, but the gun issue came out, and it really like, it just made no sense, because there were so many people getting so mad about it that they weren't going to buy it for that reason, and I'm like, 'That has no bearing!'”
business_signal: Haggis Pinball entered liquidation in August 2024, causing significant financial losses for direct customers and dealers
high · Greg Bone: 'Haggis Pinball goes into liquidation...a lot of people lost money...a lot of those a lot of people that bought direct lost money...that's horrible...another damn stain on the industry'
sentiment_shift: John Wick pinball community backlash over gun imagery was perceived as overblown and psychologically driven by pre-existing purchase resistance
medium · Zach Menny: 'from a psychological perspective, people subconsciously rationalize and they find different reasons because they weren't going to buy it anyway'
community_signal: Flippin' Out Pinball distributor protected all customers from Haggis Pinball liquidation losses despite significant personal financial impact
high · Greg Bone: 'our customers didn't lose one penny...not one...we even refunded some of customers for playfield issues'
product_concern: American Pinball's Barry's Barbecue Challenge represents fundamental misunderstanding of venue placement strategy and market appeal
high · Greg Bone criticizing barbecue venue choice: 'You picked the toughest one. A barbecue joint? Because barbecue joints are known for being quick'
design_philosophy: Jaws exemplifies preferred ruleset design philosophy where games start slow but progressively compound and open up through mode progression
medium · Zach Menny: 'once you start it rolling...it just compounds so fast and just explodes. Like, that's what I love...that's a reward for playing very well'
youtube_auto_sub · $0.000
Zach Menny@ 19:22 — Addressing community controversy over John Wick gun aesthetic and its impact on sales
“Haggis man God oh well God damn I had such high hopes for them yes you did like you did from day one you were really had a KS for a minute and ah man life sucks sometimes it do”
Greg Bone@ 26:58 — Expressing emotional impact of Haggis Pinball liquidation on the community
“People are eating it up man they love it so like and they've retired like it's it was just for 2024 so those sold out they're sold out I think that's a very smart move”
Greg Bone@ 24:00 — Praising Stern's strategic scarcity decision with Godzilla 70th Anniversary variant
licensing_signal: ABBA theme for Pinball Brothers game perceived as excessively niche with limited North American market appeal
medium · Zach Menny: 'I mean, it's ABBA...it's so niche...you've eliminated so much of your market...why?'
market_signal: Jaws achieved exceptional sales performance across all model tiers, outselling all other continuously-manufactured games in 2024
high · Greg Bone: 'Out of any title that's even still being made...Jaws collectively through the Pro, Premium, and all models, collectively was the best seller'
community_signal: Greg Ferris, head of Stern Pinball art department, retired mid-2024
high · Hosts explicitly noting 'we've seen the retirement of Greg Ferris legendary iconic artist...he was running the Stern art Department'
announcement: Stern Pinball returned to three cornerstones strategy in 2024 after previously doing two cornerstones
medium · Greg Bone stating 'In 2024 they said you know what we're going to go back to the three cornerstones because prior they were just doing like two cornerstones stuff'
product_concern: Barry's Barbecue Challenge's animation quality criticized as worse than horror-themed Texas Chainsaw Massacre
medium · Zach Menny: 'I was more grossed out watching Barry's Barbecue Challenge...than Texas Chainsaw Massacre. Not even lying. Because you've got squirty juicy meat'
sentiment_shift: Community perception of John Wick improved post-launch as code updates addressed initial shortcomings, though sales damage from poor launch persists
medium · Zach Menny: 'you've got to secure those check marks as much as you can at launch, because going back up that hill...it's not as easy'
business_signal: Stern Pinball's Godzilla 70th Anniversary Premium Edition variant with limited 2024 exclusive release and subsequent retirement was strategically successful
medium · Greg Bone: 'I think that's a very smart move' in reference to limited variant strategy and sell-out success