Journalist Tool

Kineticist

  • HDashboard
  • IItems
  • ↓Ingest
  • SSources
  • KBeats
  • BBriefs
  • RIntel
  • QSearch
  • NName Review
  • +Health

v0.1.0

← Back to items

Episode 1225: "Why I'm Never Buying Transformers & How Excited I am for The Fifth Element!"

Kaneda's Pinball Podcast (Patreon feed)·podcast_episode·20m 46s·held·May 27, 2026
View original

Analysis

claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 · $0.030

TL;DR

Kaneda condemns Transformers execution, hypes Sonic & Fifth Element rumor, analyzes pinball design trends.

Summary

Kaneda discusses his severe disappointment with Stern's Transformers pinball machine due to Optimus Prime's inability to transform without breaking, declaring he will never purchase it. He contrasts this with excitement for Jersey Jack's upcoming Sonic the Hedgehog and a rumored Fifth Element game from Pinball Brothers, while analyzing broader trends in pinball design, code quality, and manufacturing reliability across the industry.

Key Claims

  • Transformers was engineered to have Optimus Prime transform but the feature was removed or disabled before launch due to durability concerns

    high confidence · Kaneda cites promotional video from two weeks prior showing it working, states 'It was working as of two weeks ago because we saw it in the promotional video'

  • Pokemon has received zero meaningful code updates for over a month despite having a dedicated team

    medium confidence · Kaneda states 'Another month has gone by. Zero code updates. The last code update was insignificant.'

  • Transformers has significantly more code depth than Pokemon despite releasing after it

    medium confidence · Kaneda asks 'How can Transformers have 10 times more in it code-wise and the game came out after Pokemon?'

  • 40 Pokemon Limited Editions are currently for sale, indicating poor market reception and failed secondary market value

    medium confidence · Kaneda observes '40 Pokemon LEs for sale' and connects this to code quality issues

  • Fifth Element is in development at Pinball Brothers as an upcoming pinball machine

    medium confidence · Kaneda states 'we get this rumor of the fifth element and Pinball Brothers making the fifth element' and discusses it extensively as a rumor

  • Sonic the Hedgehog may have tight shots on the playfield that could lead to bricking issues

    low confidence · Kaneda reports 'I heard that the shots are a little tight' and expresses concern about 10-11 shots in fan layout compared to Pokemon's 6

  • Predator (Pinball Brothers) only made 300 units and lacks Arnold Schwarzenegger as a playable character

    high confidence · Kaneda states 'They only made 300' and 'it's without Arnold' and criticizes this as a major flaw

  • Goonies, Back to the Future, and potentially Fifth Element are all coming by end of year

    medium confidence · Kaneda states 'I'm confirming it's Goonies, Back to the Future, and maybe Fifth Element' at end of year

Notable Quotes

  • “How could you, Stern? How could you take the easiest assignment in the world and fumble it? You make a Transformer game without Optimus transforming.”

    Kaneda @ early in episode — Core thesis: Transformers' fatal design flaw makes it unsaleable despite other qualities

  • “I could never own the game now. I'm not going to buy it. I'm not even going to buy an LE of the game. I'm not going to support a company that can't execute a non-negotiable.”

    Kaneda @ early in episode — Explicit consumer rejection signal; boycott stance

  • “Transformers is going to go down as a total miss in the pinball industry. There is no way people are going to stand over that game.”

    Kaneda @ mid-episode — Prediction of Transformers' long-term market failure

  • “The solution was don't launch the game until you figure out a solve... I don't need Optimus to be hit. Why does he need to be bashed?”

    Kaneda @ mid-episode — Specific critique of design decision and implied solution path Stern missed

  • “Fifth Element to me is up there in my supernal realm. It's like Acura, Big Trouble in Little China, it's Fifth Element, it's Transformers G1, right there.”

    Kaneda @ late in episode — Demonstrates extreme enthusiasm for Fifth Element theme; highest tier preference

  • “I'm actually more excited about The Fifth Element than I would be of Back to the Future even just because I think it's a tighter single movie to make a pinball experience around.”

    Kaneda @ late in episode — Direct comparison of Fifth Element favorability over established major title

  • “If they make The Fifth Element with Corben Dallas and Lilu and Multi-Pass and Zork, this movie is perfect for pinball. The world under glass is right there in front of them.”

    Kaneda @ late in episode — Design analysis of Fifth Element's pinball potential; optimism about execution

  • “Don't buy Transformers. Trust me. Don't support a company that can't execute right.”

Entities

KanedapersonStern PinballcompanyJersey Jack PinballcompanyPinball BrotherscompanyTransformersgameSonic the HedgehoggameThe Fifth Elementgame

Signals

  • ?

    product_concern: Transformers features Optimus Prime toy that cannot transform during play due to mechanical durability constraints, despite being engineered to do so pre-launch; promotional materials from 2 weeks prior showed functional transformation

    high · Kaneda: 'It was working as of two weeks ago because we saw it in the promotional video' and 'you engineered it to be one way and yet you bought it in a way that doesn't do anything'

  • ?

    code_update: Pokemon receives zero meaningful code updates over month-long period despite dedicated development team; promised topper still unreleased; previous update described as insignificant

    high · Kaneda: 'Another month has gone by. Zero code updates. The last code update was insignificant. The topper, which was supposed to come out right away, is still not out.'

  • $

    market_signal: 40 Pokemon Limited Edition machines reported for sale, indicating failed secondary market value and poor collector confidence; Kaneda attributes this to weak code support

    medium · Kaneda: '40 Pokemon LEs for sale, yeah, I don't think a lot of other people are very happy as well' and notes they 'could have scalped those machines for more money. They're never going to get it.'

  • ?

    rumor_hype: Fifth Element pinball machine from Pinball Brothers reported as rumor; Kaneda expresses extreme enthusiasm and predicts instant sell-out if announced; positioned as dream theme alongside Big Trouble in Little China and G1 Transformers

    low · Kaneda: 'we get this rumor of the fifth element and Pinball Brothers making the fifth element' and later 'If they announce they're making just like a thousand fifth element games. I put up a picture yesterday... nothing but love for this theme.'

Transcript

groq_whisper · $0.062

0:00
Box on the run, we scream and everybody comes around and take the run and hide yourself away. Box on the run, sit up, sit up, sit up, sit up, sit up, sit up, sit up, sit up, sit up. Welcome everybody to the world's second best pinball podcaster, your host Kaneda. Happy morning, happy afternoon if you joined me for the Patreon live at like 3.30 in the morning. Went to bed last night really early. It was good. My circadian rhythm. I just listened to my body. I go horizontal and I'm out cold. I woke up and I thought to myself, how could you? You know, I can't shake it. I know it's like beating a dead horse, but how could you, Stern? How could you take the easiest assignment in the world and fumble it? You make a Transformer game without Optimus transforming. We knew it was in the plan. It was in the blueprint. And I could never own the game now. I'm not going to buy it. I'm not even going to buy an LE of the game. I'm not going to support a company that can't execute a non-negotiable. This is a fatal flaw execution in my honest opinion. I don't care how fun it is. I could never play Transformers, look down at that game and not feel what could have been. Name me another game where you've stood over it and you're looking down at it and something is just such a miss and you knew they engineered it to be one way and yet you bought it in a way that doesn't do anything. Name me another game. When we bought Jaws, I didn't buy Jaws, but a lot of people did. When people bought Jaws, that shark, yeah, it didn't eat the ball, but they didn't yank out a working shark that ate the ball at the 11th hour. So I'm also feeling like, and I'm looking at this new car Ferrari just launched, that's hideous, and everyone's making fun of it, this EV car for $640,000, and I'm feeling something in the world. I'm feeling like a brand needs to work extra hard to justify the prices of all of these luxury goods. Pinball is on a smaller scale a luxury good and if you want to maintain your audience you have to keep providing the right kind of value and I think what's happening in Pinball right now is really exciting because we're about to get I think both ends of the spectrum. Stern Pinball came out with Transformers. Within 30 days, we're going to see Sonic the Hedgehog from Jersey Jack. And I think both companies couldn't have a different design philosophy. I think Stern Pinball designs things to be good enough. They're getting a little bit better in certain areas. The code is great when they actually get it out the door. But look, I'm looking at my Pokemon right now. Another month has gone by. Zero code updates. The last code update was insignificant. The topper, which was supposed to come out right away, is still not out. So what are they doing every day? There's a whole team of people working on Pokemon code. They're not doing anything that's reaching consumers. I'm really worried. How can Transformers have 10 times more in it code-wise and the game came out after Pokemon? So yeah, I'm not a very happy camper. And when I see 40 Pokemon LEs for sale, yeah, I don't think a lot of other people are very happy as well. Because if Pokemon Code was insane on day one and the game was as great as it might be one day, then yeah, those guys probably could have scalped those machines for more money. They're never going to get it. And Sonic's going to take the wind out of the sails of not only Pokemon, but also Transformers. But I'm starting to hear things, rumblings, if you will, whispers in the dark. I think a lot of people, not the newbies, because the newbie guys are still like unsure what the heck they just became a part of. And I mean that. Like there's newbies. Even as of yesterday, people are like, so is Sonic going to be the voices from the movie? And I'm like, wait a minute. You're a member of Canada's Pinball Podcast. I talk about this every day. Now speaking of newbies I want to welcome everybody that just joined Canada Pinball Podcast this month We got Max Fry Ramp Master Justin Crapio my boy Crapio at a month I also want to thank Max for being at a month We got Eric We got J who was gifted This is great J was gifted a membership at a month We got Damian Haldi We got Breeze We got Kelly Mountain We got Jason Goldfarb Tobin Flynn and Dog Days rounding out Everybody, welcome to the Canada Club. I was a little bit shocked to see all of you guys, man. I know you guys, you are the big hitters on the Patreon. You're the big hitters when it comes to buying so many games. A lot of you guys have been buying games that lose $3,000 a month and everybody's at $5 a month subscription. Think about it. That is $60 a year for everything you get here. And these dudes are losing three to five thousand dollars on one Stern LE. Do the math on how many years of support for Canada's Pinball Podcast you could give instead of losing five grand on a Stern LE. OK, but here's the thing. I think only the newbies are really the ones that are going to keep falling victim to all of these like overpriced Stern machines. But also what I'm hearing in Pinball is this. I think we're reaching a point now where certain aspects of Pinball have really, really improved. The artwork in games is phenomenal. Games like Beetlejuice, look at that thing. Evil Dead, look at that thing. I even think Pokemon's artwork is really nice. A lot of these games are looking stunning. Harry Potter artwork, look at that thing. We've reached a point now where across the board, pinball machines are more beautiful than they've ever been probably in the history of pinball. That's good news. We've reached a point now where the code, when it's done right, is very, very satisfying. Long, long replay value, a lot to achieve, a lot to strive for in a game, and also just the way the games make you feel. I think we're reaching a point now, too, where there's like a lot of really, really good music in pinball. We don't talk a lot about music in Pinball, but it is such an important element of Pinball. We got Dirty Pool over their barrels. Look at the work he's done on Labyrinth and on Winchester and on Dune. Really, when I hear people talk about these games and the reason why they immerse you so well in the game, it's because the music is incredible. It pulls you in. I would say there's not enough of that in every single Pinball machine. I think more pinball machines need to really think about the music and how that plays such an important part. When it comes to design and layout, this is the interesting part. I would argue that the design and layout of pinball machines, there's only oh so much you can do. And there's only oh so much real estate when it comes to layout and design. And then the hard part is making sure the game itself is a lot of fun to shoot, not just on the first plunge, But on the 1000th plunge. And that's the hard part. When I think about games like Beetlejuice, the one element of Beetlejuice that seems to be the weakest part is you're just not hearing the level of satisfaction on a gameplay front. And that could be an issue because I've been hearing people who own games like Predator and Beetlejuice. And when put side to side and you ask them like which game is more fun to play, which one is more fun to shoot, which one pulls you in, which one gets you energized, which one is the one that's just like a better overall total pinball experience. And it almost kills me to say this because it doesn't have Arnold in it, but I've been speaking to people that have both games and they're like Predator is the better game. And that blows me away in a lot of ways. And it goes against my prejudice against that machine. And I think a lot of us are hearing this feedback. Games like Dune are like a 50 50. Like I hear when Dune is working, it is absolutely an incredible pin. But I also hear that it breaks down a lot and reliability is a big issue. For those of you out there, if you've ever owned a pin, there's nothing worse than it having an issue. It is basically inoperable when something goes down. And so, yeah, like I'm hearing issues on Winchester, issues on Dune. I think that's Barrels is really their next challenge is to get the manufacturing consistency and the quality to a level where people aren't popping the hood on these games. And it's hard because I know now there's still like a little bit of a delay period because they're waiting on parts. I think there's moments in the company, too, where like labor is an issue. We don't ever talk about that. Think about it. When a pinball company has a delay on parts coming in what do they do with the people every day that are manufacturing the games What do they do with that labor Are those people coming into work with absolutely nothing to do They might come in and do a little sub work but then if they can move it to the next station because the part not in there nothing for them to do That the hardest part You know, because then you have to pay those people and they're not making games and every day they're not making games, you're not making money. Or you got to tell those people they're not going to be paid and then they're going to go get another job and then you got to start over again and train those people. But look, here's where I think we're at. I think Stern Pinball Transformers is going to go down as a total miss in the pinball industry. I don't care what the code is. There is no way people are going to stand over that game. And there's no way the mod community is going to be able to fix the issue with the game. I put up a poll. Everybody agrees for the most part what the solution is. It wasn't putting the transforming optimist into the LE only. The solution was don't launch the game until you figure out a solve. And if the solve is to move Optimus to another part of the game so that he can transform without him being bashed and breaking any of the linkage, that's a solution. I don't need Optimus to be hit. I don't even think he should be hit. Why does he need to be bashed? I think Optimus Prime should have transformed in a place on the game where he doesn't break. That toy is like 40 bucks at Walmart. Hasbro gave you a toy that was already engineered. All you had to do was scale it down a little bit and make it work for Pinball and you had two and a half years to do it and you couldn't do it. And it was working as of two weeks ago because we saw it in the promotional video. So this game is going to get forgotten very, very quickly. Then we're going to get Sonic. I think it's going to be great. The other rumor I'm hearing about Sonic and we'll see. I haven't played it yet. I don't know. I heard that the shots are a little tight. I hope that's not the case. We heard that Steve had to open up the ramps a little bit. But in the playfield image I have, you can see there's so many shots. There's like, I don't know, like 10 or 11 shots going across a fan layout. That to me is a little concerning because I've got a Pokemon where there's like six shots going across in the fan layout. And every single shot is buttery smooth and fun to hit. And if you're adding in a lot more shots, I might be a little worried that there's going to be a lot of bricking up and down in that game. We're going to know in just a few weeks. So that game is going to come out. And then out of nowhere, we get this rumor of the fifth element and Pinball Brothers making the fifth element. I want to talk about this because you know this is a dream theme of mine. This is a Take My Money Now theme more so than G1 Transformers because I think people are forgetting the Take My Money Now Transformers was not the series. It was Transformers the movie. I still think Transformers the movie is a way better theme and has way better potential for an exciting pinball experience because of the drama in that movie, because of the characters, the music, the soundtrack, Unicron, Galvatron, Megatron. It's all in there and then some. That has the moments of magic. I don't really remember like the Dinobots or them going up to a golden lake. I know there's all these different moments in the game right now, but I don't remember those moments as much as I remember Megatron versus Optimus and Optimus dying and Ultra Magnus trying to open up the matrix of leadership and going in front of the Quintessons and being told guilty or innocent, innocent. And all those scenes with dare and dare to be stupid and you got the touch. It's a pity you Autobots die so easily or I might have a greater sense of satisfaction. Arise, Rodimus Prime. All of that, man. I remember all of that. I've seen that movie like a thousand times. I don't have the same like goosebumps when I watch the TV show. So but Fifth Element to me is up there in my supernal realm. It's like Acura, Big Trouble in Little China, it's Fifth Element, it's Transformers G1, right there. Give me those and I'd be a happy man for the rest of my pinball life. Now, Pinball Brothers is a company that needs to make a statement. Predator will never recover. They only made 300. The big difference at Pinball Brothers now is that they making their games with Aaron over at Fast and the word of mouth has been great on the Predator game on how it powered on how it holding up It just missing the main mech which is Arnold So if they make the fifth element and I have to assume that they have Bruce Willis in it If they make this game and it's without Bruce Willis, the same way that Predator is without Arnold, and you're playing as Bruce Willis, don't make it. I don't know how you do that because he's in like every single scene. So I'm going to assume that they learn their lesson and this game has Bruce Willis in it. Now, is he allowing himself to be licensed? We know everything he's going through medically right now and it's a very sad story, but maybe they want him to be remembered with all of these things now and maybe they're going to give the green light to put Bruce in his heyday out there in the world. I mean, the pitch I would always do if I were a pinball company, I would try to meet with the families of the people that control these estates and say, look, there's no greater honor than to have a pinball machine based on one of your most iconic roles. We cannot pay the typical licensing fee because the volume of these things is so small. Let us do this. Let us show you what we could do and then make up your mind. Everything's a negotiation at the end of the day. So if they make The Fifth Element with Corbin Dallas and Lilu and Multi-Pass and Zork, this movie is perfect for pinball. The world under glass is right there in front of them. I'm actually more excited about The Fifth Element than I would be of Back to the Future even just because I think it's a tighter single movie to make a pinball experience around. It's also like one of Brenda's favorite movies. Every time it's on, I love it. I love the memories of going into the theater and seeing the fifth element for the first time and having no idea what I was about to witness. And it blew me away. So if this rumor is true, let's think about this. When would this game be coming out? Do we think they'd be ready to bring this game out sometime by the end of the year? Is this something that would be at Expo? Can you imagine that? That we get the fifth element and back to the future available at the same exact time. Pinball Brothers is also a company that can't make a lot of games a year. So if this is true and fifth element is coming out, this game is going to be a crazy seller for them. It will sell out instantly if they announce they're making just like a thousand fifth element games. I put up a picture yesterday. Other than people making fun of the Pinball Brothers here and there, nothing but love for this theme. Nothing but love. I don't know how you could be a grown man that's into action, into sci-fi, and into comedy that doesn't love this movie. It has all three of those in spades. It's also one of Bruce Willis' greatest movies of all time. Okay, so this now makes the year even more interesting as we get to the end of the year in which Goonies, which I'm confirming it's Goonies, Back to the Future, and maybe Fifth Element. You know what's going to be hard are all these remakes and remasters. I think it's going to be hard for Circus Voltaire and for Toten. I don't know what they're waiting for. Apparently this Toten game was in California and then they never put it on the floor. I think they're reworking some stuff. You know, it's just going to feel like a day late and a dollar short. I don't think that Brian Allen on artwork is going to move these games, especially at over $10,000 a pop. I don't think it's going to happen. I think there's too much stuff that's new that people want. And I think these guys are all waiting too long. They're waiting too long. It's like American Pinball announced Circus Voltaire and then what, crickets for four or five months? That's not good marketing. What's the point of that? It's almost like, do you think anyone's going to hold on to their money because you're bringing back something that's like 35 years old? Same thing with Toten. You got a hit when there's a window. And I don't even think there's going to be a window. I really don't. There's just too much new stuff coming out. Six years ago, you could get away with these remasters. Now, I just don't even see where the window is. I think people are just out of space. They're out of space, too. So it's about to get really, really interesting. Ladies and gentlemen, next week is June. We're going to see Sonic. It's going to happen. Can't wait. More Canadian Pinball podcasts coming. Don't buy Transformers. Trust me. Don't support a company that can't execute right. Don't buy it. And if you really want it and need it, Just wait and the prices on this game are going to plummet. Trust me. Canada out.

Kaneda @ closing segment — Final consumer recommendation; anti-Stern stance

Pokemon
game
Predatorgame
Gooniesgame
Back to the Futuregame
Beetlejuicegame
Evil Deadgame
Dunegame
Winchestergame
Barrels of Funcompany
Circus Voltairegame
Totemgame
Harry Pottergame
American Pinballcompany
Aaronperson
Dirty Poolperson
Hasbrocompany
?

design_concern: Sonic the Hedgehog may feature overly tight shot spacing with 10-11 shots in fan layout (vs Pokemon's 6), raising concerns about brick frequency and playability

low · Kaneda: 'I heard that the shots are a little tight... there's like 10 or 11 shots going across a fan layout. That to me is a little concerning... I might be a little worried that there's going to be a lot of bricking up and down in that game'

  • ~

    sentiment_shift: Kaneda signals declining consumer confidence in Stern's ability to execute complex licensed themes competently; publicly recommends avoiding Transformers despite potential gameplay merits

    high · Kaneda: 'Don't buy Transformers. Trust me. Don't support a company that can't execute right' and 'prices on this game are going to plummet'

  • ?

    competitive_signal: Jersey Jack positioned as superior design philosophy to Stern; Sonic expected to cannibalize sales from both Pokemon and Transformers within 30-day window

    high · Kaneda: 'I think both companies couldn't have a different design philosophy... Sonic's going to take the wind out of the sails of not only Pokemon, but also Transformers'

  • ?

    product_concern: Dune and Winchester experiencing significant reliability issues; Barrels of Fun struggling with manufacturing consistency and quality control; parts delays and labor management compounding problems

    high · Kaneda: 'I'm hearing issues on Winchester, issues on Dune... reliability is a big issue' and discusses labor costs during parts shortages

  • ?

    design_philosophy: Pinball artwork across industry has reached all-time high quality; multiple recent titles (Beetlejuice, Evil Dead, Pokemon, Harry Potter) praised for visual aesthetics

    high · Kaneda: 'across the board, pinball machines are more beautiful than they've ever been probably in the history of pinball' citing Beetlejuice, Evil Dead, Pokemon, Harry Potter

  • $

    market_signal: Remasters (Circus Voltaire, Totem) face declining market window due to new content competition; long marketing gaps between announcement and release damage momentum; market saturation predicted

    medium · Kaneda: 'It's going to be hard for Circus Voltaire and for Toten... You got a hit when there's a window. And I don't even think there's going to be a window... There's just too much new stuff coming out'

  • ?

    personnel_signal: Pinball Brothers collaborating with Aaron over at Fast for manufacturing; partnership credited with quality improvements and positive word-of-mouth on Predator

    high · Kaneda: 'Pinball Brothers now is that they making their games with Aaron over at Fast and the word of mouth has been great on the Predator game'

  • ?

    licensing_signal: Fifth Element licensing may hinge on negotiations with Bruce Willis estate regarding his image rights; Kaneda speculates health considerations may make estate willing to grant licensing for legacy preservation

    low · Kaneda: 'We know everything he's going through medically right now and it's a very sad story, but maybe they want him to be remembered... maybe they're going to give the green light to put Bruce in his heyday'

  • 20:30
    Jaws on the run.