claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 · $0.035
Jaws release analysis: design decisions, leaked trailers, licensing constraints, Chief Brody absence, and artwork reception.
Keith Elwin was wearing a Jaws hat at Pinburgh in 2018, six years before the game's release, essentially trolling the community about the game's development.
high confidence · Josh and Scott discussing leaked information about Keith Elwin's early knowledge of the Jaws project, mentioning Stern Insider Podcast revealed this detail.
The original shark-eating-ball mechanic was abandoned because it looked 'really dumb' and had technical issues with ball routing and the lack of a subway system in the playfield design.
high confidence · Detailed explanation from Stern Insider Podcast, with Scott and Josh discussing why the mechanic was scrapped in favor of a captive ball design with drop target.
The shark fin drop target was originally designed as an actual shark fin, but tests showed the ball launching unpredictably due to shark fins being 'nature's natural ramps,' forcing a design change to the drop target.
high confidence · Keith Elwin explained mechanics in Stern Insider Podcast; Josh and Scott reference this explanation directly.
The upper playfield was designed to prevent players from staying up there indefinitely, with two exit shots (steering wheel and horseshoe loop) that route the ball back to main play.
high confidence · Josh explains the upper playfield design philosophy, contrasting it with problematic upper playfield designs on other games like Whitewater.
Richard Dreyfuss provided vocal recordings for the game, though his voice is noticeably different after 50 years compared to the original 1975 film.
high confidence · Josh and Scott discuss Richard Dreyfuss vocals, mentioning Jerry Thompson addressed voice aging in Stern Insider Podcast.
Chief Brody's face is not prominent on the playfield despite being a major character, with licensing constraints from the movie estate being tighter than expected.
high confidence · Josh and Scott discuss Brody's limited visual presence but inclusion through movie clips and the wizard mode title 'Smile, You Son of a –' (a Brody line).
The leaked teaser trailer caused initial negative sentiment by showing grainy, unflattering photos that made the playfield appear empty, which was reversed by the official Gomez-Elwin full trailer.
“It's like an explosion of news. I've got these notes that are just a mile long.”
Josh Roop @ Opening — Sets the tone for the episode's coverage of major pinball industry news and announcements.
“Keith, you played with a Star Wars toy back in the 80s. You were totally trolling us.”
Scott Larson @ Early in episode — Humorous commentary on how designers have long histories of easter eggs and hints in their work.
“They said it looked really dumb. It wasn't working, right.”
Scott Larson @ Design discussion — Explains the practical engineering constraints that force design changes despite fan desires.
“Because you think of the T-Rex head on Jack Danger's game too. It just sits there and it opens. You've got like Gene Simmons Kiss. Like you've just got this big ugly head sitting there that's just essentially a scoop.”
Josh Roop @ Mechanics discussion — Comparative analysis of scoop-based mechanics across pinball games, highlighting design trade-offs.
“That is the most brutal metal thing you've ever seen?”
Scott Larson @ Artwork discussion — Strong praise for Michael Bernard's Premium backglass art showing Quint being eaten by the shark.
“Is it not Richard Dreyfuss? They got vocals from Richard Dreyfuss, which is awesome.”
Josh Roop @ Content discussion — Highlights a major licensing achievement and authentic star voice inclusion in the game.
“When I first saw Jaws from the photos, I was a little disappointed. I was like, what?”
Josh Roop @ Leak discussion — Demonstrates the negative impact of leaked photos before the official trailer changed community perception.
“This is what turned people around. I was talking to a handful of people across this industry...they said that they saw an instant turnaround because Steam died really quick.”
Scott Larson — Shows the importance of professional marketing in reversing negative sentiment from leaks.
community_signal: Michael Bernard (artist) engaged with community feedback about Rush art criticism by creating humorous response showing detailed close-up of Quint and Hooper faces.
medium · Josh: 'he posted, he's like, I know you guys were complaining about the Rush heads, so here is a close-up of Quint and Hooper.'
event_signal: Loser Kid Pinball Podcast celebrating its 5-year anniversary (January 11, 2019 to January 2024) with episode dedicated to Jaws release and mental health awareness messaging.
high · Josh: 'Our first episode released January 11th in 2019' and dedication to Brittany Staley and mental health discussion throughout opening.
competitive_signal: Jaws positioned as potential successor to Godzilla as top-rated game on Pinside, with Jaws being referred to internally at Stern as 'Keith's masterpiece' following Godzilla's success.
high · Josh: 'we had been hearing from multiple sources that this had been internally called at Stern Keith's masterpiece...I have a really high bar to meet with Godzilla.'
design_philosophy: Keith Elwin intentionally designed upper playfield to prevent indefinite play retention, a departure from problematic upper playfield design on other games like Whitewater.
high · Josh: 'Keith is not a fan of upper playfields because a lot of times you can get up there and stay up there indefinitely. So his goal was to make an upper playfield but make it so where like you couldn't stay up there.'
leak_detection: Jaws teaser trailer leaked over a month before official announcement, with grainy photos following within 12-24 hours of official teaser, spreading across content creators' channels before Stern's official Gomez-Elwin trailer.
groq_whisper · $0.213
high confidence · Josh and Scott discuss the impact of leaks: 'Steam died really quick when those photos started to leak. And when that video came out...people understood what was going on.'
Michael Bernard created three different art packages (Pro, Premium, LE) with the Pro and LE using the iconic Jaws movie poster, while the Premium features original artwork of Quint being eaten by the shark.
high confidence · Josh and Scott praise Michael Bernard's Premium art package as superior to other tiers, with Josh noting it as his favorite art package.
Godzilla currently ranks #1 on Pinside ratings, surpassing Medieval Madness, and Jaws is being positioned to potentially follow as Keith Elwin's 'masterpiece' project.
high confidence · Josh states: 'I never saw when I got into the hobby that a game would actually surpass Medieval Madness for number one on the Pinside rating' but Godzilla did.
Flippin' Out Pinball (Zach and Nicole Minney) is taking orders for Jaws and has been 'hit up pretty hard' with strong demand immediately following the announcement.
high confidence · Josh recommends contacting Flippin' Out Pinball for Jaws orders, noting they're busy and have been receiving heavy interest.
“Everything in your body can get sick, including your mind. And the best thing you can do is reach out and get help that targets the organ that is hurting.”
Scott Larson @ Mental health segment — Personal testimony on mental health importance in the pinball community context.
“I feel like this is like maybe like a Groot. Well, not a Groot. What am I looking for? Sparky off of Metallica...The Well Walker.”
Josh Roop @ Mechanical discussion — Comparative analysis of unique playfield mechanics across different pinball machines.
high · Josh: 'the trailer was leaked over a month ago...It's always like a grainy trailer...By the time this actually had come out, it had already had 20,000 views combined over other content creators.'
licensing_signal: Chief Brody character has limited visual presence on playfield despite being central to the film, suggesting licensing constraints from the movie estate are tight, though character appears through clips and wizard mode title.
high · Josh: 'it seems like when it comes to estates, they're a lot more tight-fisted on what they're saying' and discussion of Brody's absence from playfield despite inclusion through movie clips.
market_signal: Flippin' Out Pinball reporting high demand for Jaws immediately following announcement, with Zach and Nicole Minney described as 'a little busy right now' and 'hit up pretty hard.'
high · Josh: 'If you want to get on that Jaws list, hit up Flippin' Out Pinball. Zach and Nicole Minney will take care of your every need. They're a little busy right now. It sounds like they've been hit up pretty hard.'
market_signal: Official Gomez-Elwin full trailer (5.5 minutes) reversed negative sentiment caused by leaked grainy photos, showing the importance of professional marketing presentation over user-generated leaks.
high · Scott: 'Steam died really quick when those photos started to leak. And when that video came out...people understood what was going on with the game.' Josh: 'When I first saw Jaws from the photos, I was a little disappointed...after they went through and explained what they're doing...this is amazing.'
community_signal: Keith Elwin's design process involved extensive iteration and testing, with original ideas (shark fin ramp, ball-eating mech) abandoned after finding technical and aesthetic issues during development.
high · Scott: 'Keith and company originally had that shaped as a shark fin...they said the ball was launching every – like it was unpredictable...they had to go to a drop target.'
product_strategy: Jaws features three distinct art packages with Pro/LE using iconic movie poster and Premium featuring original Michael Bernard artwork of Quint being consumed by shark.
high · Josh: 'the Pro flyer, the backglass is the movie poster...the Premium flyer – that was just fun. When I saw that he was able to do the shark chewing the Orca up.'
product_strategy: Original shark-eating-ball mechanic was abandoned during development in favor of captive ball design with drop target due to visual and technical issues with ball routing.
high · Scott: 'the ball-eating mech looks stupid. And it was hard because of the way it came out of the playfield...the game was not designed to have a subway in it. So what, it's going to eat the ball and then spit it back out at you?'
technology_signal: Jaws trailer embed in pinball machine code updates suggests pre-recorded trailers may be data-mined weeks before release, raising questions about code security and leak prevention.
medium · Josh and Scott discuss whether Jaws trailer appearing in code updates 'six weeks before release' indicates code download with timestamp vs. streaming architecture, speculating data miners could extract trailers early.