claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 · $0.034
BW Godzilla release strategy and X-Men '97 speculation amid market saturation concerns.
Stern released Godzilla B/W as Premium package (not LE) to avoid angering LE buyers after 2023 backlash from Jurassic Park 30th and Elvira 40th Anniversary releases
high confidence · Josh theorizes this was originally planned as LE but strategy changed; uses LE artwork and mirrors cabinet design
Godzilla was released in September 2021 (not March 2021 as initially stated)
high confidence · Scott corrects himself after looking it up; three year gap between original release and B/W variant
Rush license was renewed and Stern plans to produce more units due to ongoing demand
medium confidence · Josh mentions Stern 'just renewed the license for Rush and they might be running. They said they're going to run more of those'
Rush likely had only 1-2 production runs of Pro models before discontinuation
medium confidence · Josh: 'I want to say they only did like one run, I really think, maybe two on the Pros'
Secondary market for recent Stern games shows price softening and inventory buildup (Venoms at $4,000+, Foo Fighters flooding market)
high confidence · Scott observes Venom Pro at $5,000, Walking Dead 10-year-old modded at ~$4,700; notes Foo Fighters and Venom inventory glut
Keith Elwin is intentionally recreating and improving upon classic game designs (Godzilla as better Medieval Madness, Jaws as better Attack from Mars)
medium confidence · Josh theory: 'I really feel like Keith Elwin is taking a stab at some of the best games ever made' with better flow than originals
X-Men '97 rumored as next John Borg release, but hosts skeptical this makes strategic sense vs Wolverine/Deadpool themed game
low confidence · Josh: 'Borg is rumored to be next in the pipeline' for X-Men '97; calls it 'weird strategy to release essentially the same game twice'
Stern maintains relationship with Disney and releases Disney properties approximately every 18 months
medium confidence · Scott: 'Stern and Disney have a relationship. They do. And they tend to do Disney properties, it seems like, once every 18 months'
“My thought is this was originally supposed to be an LE release, but after the pitchforks came out last year, they're like, 'You know what? We'll call it a Premium.'”
Josh Roop @ ~15:00 — Josh's theory explaining Stern's strategic shift away from multiple LE releases on same title
“Stern makes games quicker than anybody... But when you look at like an Attack from Mars Special Edition, you are very aware that it is not the same as the LE.”
Scott Larson @ ~25:00 — Comparison highlighting Stern's superior tier differentiation strategy vs Chicago Gaming Company
“I'd probably sell off my Godzilla to get the black and white. I just think it's that good looking.”
Scott Larson @ ~30:00 — Strong endorsement of B/W variant aesthetic despite owner having modded original
“I really feel like Keith Elwin is taking a stab at some of the best games ever made... it's a better flow. It's a better game in my opinion.”
Josh Roop @ ~50:00 — Josh's theory about Elwin's design philosophy and relationship to pinball canon
“I just find it would be really weird to be the exact same layout... I will be the first to stand up and say I was dead wrong if it ends up being X-Men '97, but that doesn't make sense to me.”
Josh Roop @ ~42:00 — Explicit skepticism about X-Men '97 rumor and preference for Wolverine/Deadpool theme
“Stern is, number one, a pinball manufacturer... They're quite tuned in on what is selling at the time.”
Scott Larson @ ~10:00 — Explanation of Stern's strategic inventory management and release scheduling
“Are people getting—is the FOMO gone?”
Josh Roop @ ~48:00 — Key question about changing market dynamics and collector behavior
“If you're gonna do a cartoon version of a big favorite... I would have chosen [Batman Beyond]. I truly do not understand doing the X-Men '97 theme.”
business_signal: Rush limited production likely due to niche band appeal; renewal and rerun indicates manufacturer maintaining evergreen catalog items for steady revenue
medium · Scott: 'Rush is a niche band'; Josh: 'only did like one run, maybe two on the Pros' before discontinuation; now restarting production
sentiment_shift: Collector skepticism about X-Men '97 strategic choice; preference for Wolverine/Deadpool licensing with Ryan Reynolds cameo potential
medium · Josh and Scott both express doubt about X-Men '97 vs alternatives; suggest Wolverine/Deadpool as superior Disney/MCU choice
design_philosophy: Keith Elwin theorized to be intentionally recreating and improving classic game designs from pinball canon
medium · Josh: 'I really feel like Keith Elwin is taking a stab at some of the best games ever made' - Godzilla as Medieval Madness upgrade, Jaws as Attack from Mars upgrade
licensing_signal: Stern maintains 18-month release cadence with Disney properties, indicating structured IP licensing relationship and portfolio planning
medium · Scott: 'they tend to do Disney properties, it seems like, once every 18 months' noting Venom, Star Wars, Avengers pattern
market_signal: Secondary market showing price compression and inventory buildup on recent Stern releases (Venom $4-5k, Foo Fighters flooding market); suggests demand softening
high · Scott observes Venom Pro at $5k, Walking Dead 10yr-old at $4.7k, hosts noting Foo Fighters inventory glut and competitive secondary pricing
groq_whisper · $0.238
Scott Larson @ ~40:00 — Alternative theme suggestion and critique of X-Men '97 strategic choice
community_signal: Potential design philosophy shift at Stern under Keith Elwin toward intentional canon references and classic game homages
low · Josh theory about Elwin recreating Medieval Madness and Attack from Mars as improved versions; not confirmed by Stern
market_signal: Market showing resistance to high Premium/LE prices as secondary markets soften; collector portfolio saturation limiting new purchases
medium · Josh: 'I have eight games in my garage stacked up in storage. Like, which one is going to supplant that?' questioning purchase rationale for similar-themed games
announcement: Stern renewed Rush license and announced continued production to fulfill ongoing demand
medium · Josh: 'they just renewed the license for Rush and they might be running. They said they're going to run more of those'
product_concern: Godzilla B/W aesthetic receives strong positive reception; black/white/red colorway praised as superior to original despite same layout
high · Scott: 'I'd probably sell off my Godzilla to get the black and white. I just think it's that good looking' despite having heavily modded original
rumor_hype: X-Men '97 rumored as next John Borg release; hosts express skepticism about theme choice vs Wolverine/Deadpool alternative
low · Josh: 'Borg is rumored to be next in the pipeline... the rumor is that Borg is on X-Men '97' but calls it 'weird strategy'
sentiment_shift: FOMO declining as collectors hold games longer rather than trading; games with longer shelf lives staying in collections longer
medium · Josh: 'Are people getting—is the FOMO gone?' noting some games have 5-6 month sales windows while others stay in collections
business_signal: Stern strategically shifted Godzilla B/W from LE to Premium tier to avoid repeating 2023 LE buyer backlash; indicates manufacturer recognition of collector sentiment erosion
high · Josh explicitly theorizes original LE plan abandoned post-pitchforks; uses LE artwork; Stern statement that future alt packages will be Premium only