claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 · $0.034
Haggis Fathom Revisited and Stern Mandalorian announced; debate over remake pricing and market viability.
Haggis Pinball Fathom Revisited Mermaid Edition costs $8,968 USD, standard edition $7,408 USD
high confidence · Alex confirms after looking up pricing online; Spencer initially estimates, Alex corrects with exact figures
Fathom Revisited Mermaid Edition limited to 250 units; standard edition has no production limit
high confidence · Dan states '250 limit on Mermaid,' Spencer confirms no limit on standard
Mermaid Edition includes comic book, advanced rule set, display screens for rule set cards, iridescent reflective cabinet paint
high confidence · Dan describes features in detail during product explanation
Fathom Revisited includes auto launcher and ball save features
medium confidence · Spencer states 'they already have' auto launcher; Alex believes he read about ball save 'somewhere'
Stern Mandalorian LE (750 units) sold out before announcement
high confidence · Spencer and Dan confirm all 750 LEs sold out pre-announcement; attributed to FOMO
Star Wars: The Mandalorian designed by Brian Eddy, coded by Brian Eddy and Lonnie Rock
high confidence · Spencer states these credits with confidence; no contradiction from roundtable
Mandalorian has rumored upper playfield that flips, two flippers, six drop targets, and includes Razor Crest ship
medium confidence · Spencer says 'rumor is' for upper playfield details; confirmed by Dan for Razor Crest
Beatles Gold machines selling around $6,000 on secondary market
medium confidence · Speaker mentions seeing Beatles Golds 'for six' recently
Jersey Jack Guns N' Roses basic model $8,500, limited $10,500, collectors $12,500, with $1,000 mid-run price increase
medium confidence · Speaker estimates pricing (says 'maybe 85 for basic') then acknowledges uncertainty; mentions price bump mid-run
“will it feel like a fathom? That's a great question. Those early valleys, it's got to feel man.”
Dan — Core tension: whether a modernized remake can capture the original's intangible 'feel' — central debate for classic game remakes
“I own a medieval remake, and my buddy Henry owns a medieval remake, and it couldn't be more different than mine... just every two pinball machines are different.”
Speaker (discussing CGC remakes) — Establishes variability between individual machines as a counterargument to perfectionist restoration expectations
“I'm sure they'll sell the 250 mermaids because there are enough people in this hobby right now who are just going to take a chance hoping for resale value.”
Speaker — Identifies collector/speculative demand as key sales driver for limited editions, separate from core gameplay interest
“It's full FOMO fever right now... 750 LEs. All sold out. All sold out before the announcement was made.”
Spencer — Highlights aggressive pre-announcement FOMO-driven sales strategy for premium limited editions
“Disney's got to approve it, so no she won't [Gina Carano won't be in Mandalorian].”
Speaker — Addresses contentious IP approval issue; assumes Disney intervention based on actor's contract violations/social media controversy
“you're the guy who would be like, shit. Like, this is the game for my youth. I need it. But you're also the guy who's like, I ain't spending $7,000 on a game from 1980.”
Spencer — Articulates generational nostalgia vs. pricing resistance for Fathom's target demographic
“The group of people that have that kind of disposable income that are interested in pinball. I don't think it's a huge group of people.”
Speaker — Acknowledges limited addressable market for $7-9k premium remakes despite FOMO tactics
“I'm going to enjoy one life with Steve. No, you don't. Nobody does. Because every time somebody makes one, they don't smoke for shit.”
product_launch: Haggis Pinball announces Fathom Revisited with standard and Mermaid Edition variants; limited 250 units on premium tier
high · Confirmed pricing ($7,408 standard, $8,968 Mermaid), production limits, feature set (comic, rule variants, display screens, iridescent cabinet)
product_launch: Stern Pinball Star Wars: The Mandalorian announced and pre-sold out (750 LEs) before public reveal video
high · 750 LE units sold out pre-announcement; design/coding credits confirmed (Brian Eddy, Lonnie Rock); video reveal expected 'this Tuesday'
market_signal: Stern Mandalorian sells 750 LE units before announcement; speculation about speculative resale value driving purchases
high · Spencer: 'full FOMO fever right now'; quote about collectors buying hoping for resale value; Pinsider rumor about putting game on location as 'ATM machine'
sentiment_shift: Community debate over whether Fathom Revisited can capture original's 'feel'; tension between modernization and authenticity expectations
high · Extended discussion of 'vocal minority' demanding exactness; CGC remake comparisons; Medieval Madness game-to-game variability; concern about flipper mat/coil stop differences
market_signal: Premium new game pricing ($7-9K Fathom, $8.5-12.5K Jersey Jack, $6K Beatles secondary) compresses into narrow band; buyers choosing between multiple premium options
high · Roundtable discusses buying decisions as tradeoffs; question 'do you buy one Mermaid or two classic games'; Beatles Gold at $6K mentioned as alternative
groq_whisper · $0.392
Fathom (1981) was 'one of the first ones people cared enough about to start doing restores and remanufacturing playfields for'
medium confidence · Dan's assessment of Fathom's historical significance in restoration culture
Speaker — Critiques manufacturing/QC consistency issues across batches; humorous but points to quality control variability
“what could they possibly add to it... they already have they added an auto launcher so maybe yeah I believe I read somewhere about that”
Speaker (uncertain about rule set additions) — Reveals limited information about actual rule set enhancements for Fathom Revisited beyond mechanical features
“When you're with your friends or when you're around people or stuff, man, shut up on the internet... You've got to understand you're a public figure and your words will be used against you.”
Speaker (re: Gina Carano situation) — Broader commentary on social media consequences extending beyond pinball industry; shows media/IP strategy impacts game decisions
product_concern: Variability between individual units of same game model; Medieval Madness example shows coil stop failures and ball deflection differences
medium · Speaker compares own Medieval Madness to Henry's; notes different flipper behavior, coil stop replacement required; joke about 'every time somebody makes one, they don't smoke for shit'
regulatory_signal: Gina Carano (Cara Dune actress) excluded from Mandalorian game due to contract termination; Disney approval requirement prevents inclusion
medium · Roundtable question 'will Cara Doon be in there or not'; assumption that 'Disney's got to approve it, so no she won't'; context of social media controversy/contract violation
machine_intel: Mandalorian rumored to feature upper playfield, two flippers, six drop targets, Razor Crest ship; art inspired by pre-production stills
medium · Spencer: 'rumor is the game's going to have an upper playfield'; 'two flippers and six drop targets'; art from Star Wars comic artist; 'pre-production stills' inspiration rumor
collector_signal: Mermaid Edition positioned as 250-unit exclusive with expanded rule set and premium cosmetics driving FOMO collector demand
high · Speaker: 'I'm sure they'll sell the 250 mermaids because there are enough people... going to take a chance hoping for resale value'; 'limited edition FOMO' behavior
design_innovation: Mermaid Edition features iridescent reflective paint creating light-reactive cabinet effect; display screens replace traditional rule set cards
high · Dan describes 'iridescent paint that is like reflective, makes it look like the cabinet lights up'; 'rule set cards are actually display screens'
community_signal: Fathom Revisited skewing toward older demographics (40s-60s) with disposable income and 1981 nostalgia; question about younger player adoption unresolved
high · Discussion of target age (15 years old in 1981 = 50s+ now); concern that younger players (Alex at 27) don't have disposable income yet; barcades as potential gateway for new generation
business_signal: Question whether market has sufficient demand for $7-9K Fathom Revisited at 250-unit-plus volume; concern about competition from Stern/JJP premium lines
medium · Roundtable skepticism: 'how big is the audience... I don't think it's a huge group'; 'are there enough people... to make it a success'; comparison to competing $8-12.5K premium games